West Indies, U.S.A.
A satirical poem observing the contrasts of prosperity and poverty across the Caribbean, with a sharp critique of American imperialism and racial discrimination
The simile "islands seem like dice tossed on a casino's baize" compares the Caribbean islands to dice on a gambling table, suggesting that the prosperity of each island is left to chance rather than determined by the merit or effort of its people.
The gambling metaphor continues — "takes the pot" implies Puerto Rico has won the economic lottery of the Caribbean, largely due to its association with the United States.
The allusion to Dallas — a wealthy, oil-rich city in Texas — reinforces Puerto Rico's comparative affluence. The cliché "silver linings on the clouds" ironically hints at an optimism that the poem will later undercut.
The simile "like a maverick's gold ring" presents San Juan as flashy and non-conformist — an outsider among Caribbean islands. The word "maverick" suggests Puerto Rico operates by different rules, set apart by its American ownership. This image of glitter and gold, however, foreshadows the later revelation that it is merely "fool's glitter."
The metaphor "airports are like calling cards" and "cultural fingermarks" suggests that airports serve as compact representations of each country's identity and economic condition. Each one leaves a distinct impression of the culture it belongs to.
The listing of airports across the Caribbean — Haiti, Trinidad, and Antigua — highlights underdevelopment and economic struggle. Details like "hand-written signs" and "lethargic contempt" paint a picture of neglect and disillusionment in contrast to what awaits in San Juan.
The short, blunt sentence creates a dramatic pause and contrast. "Plush" emphasises luxury, but the tone is laced with irony given what follows.
The pilot's "drawl" subtly marks him as Southern American, carrying connotations of racial tension and authority. The repetition of "stay on the plane" mimics the authoritative, dehumanising tone of American institutional control.
Irony and sarcasm dominate here. "Uncle Sam" is a metonym for the United States government. The phrase "Island of the free" is a sardonic play on the American national anthem's "land of the free," exposing the hypocrisy of America's freedom rhetoric when applied to people of colour. The word "re-enslave" is historically loaded, evoking the legacy of slavery.
The allusion to "America's backyard" references Reagan-era rhetoric about American dominance in the Caribbean. "Give me your poor" alludes to Emma Lazarus's poem engraved on the Statue of Liberty, exposing the contradiction between America's humanitarian self-image and its discriminatory practices toward Caribbean people.
The symbolism of "toughened, tinted glass" represents the barrier between the speaker and the reality of Puerto Rico — he can see it, but only through a filter, and cannot access it. It also suggests that the American lens distorts and obscures truth.
The diction "fierce efficiency" contrasts with the "lethargic contempt" of earlier Caribbean airports, highlighting how American influence transforms even labour into a militarised, impersonal operation.
The juxtaposition of "galvanised shanties" and "condominiums" is the poem's most vivid image of inequality. The word "overseen" is deliberate — the wealthy literally look down upon the poor, suggesting surveillance and dominance as well as physical elevation.
The contrast between "polished Cadillacs" and "Rastas with pushcarts" encapsulates the economic divide within San Juan. "Shimmying past" implies an almost deliberate avoidance — the wealthy skirting around the poor without acknowledgement.
The extended metaphor of a broken, stolen television set is central to the poem's conclusion. "Fool's glitter" reveals the earlier golden imagery as false. The TV "fallen off the back of a lorry" is an idiomatic reference to stolen goods, implying Puerto Rico itself was acquired by dubious means — alluding to the US annexation of the island in 1898.
The similes "roads like twisted wires" and "bright cars, micro-chips" reduce the city to broken machinery — chaotic, dysfunctional, and artificial.
The final line delivers the poem's most powerful statement. The tricolon "sharp and jagged and dangerous" accumulates to a damning verdict on Puerto Rico's condition. "Belonged to someone else" is the poem's ultimate indictment — Puerto Rico's identity, culture, and land were taken, and what remains is a broken, stolen thing.
Click any line to reveal its analysis below.
35 lines
About the poem
Author: Stewart Brown (b. 1951) Context: Written from the perspective of a traveller on a stopover flight across the Caribbean; reflects on American imperialism, racial discrimination, and economic inequality in the region
Core idea: Puerto Rico's apparent prosperity, a product of American ownership, is exposed as superficial — beneath the glitter lies deep inequality, racial oppression, and a stolen identity.
-
Main themes
- Oppression and discrimination
- Colonialism and American imperialism
- Economic inequality and class divide
- Caribbean identity
- Appearance vs. reality
- Race and racial injustice
-
Mood: Initially observational and ironic, shifting to bitter and indignant
-
Tone: Sarcastic, critical, and ultimately condemnatory
- The poem moves from aerial observation → ground-level reality → damning conclusion
- The gambling metaphor establishes that Caribbean prosperity is a matter of chance, not justice
- "Fool's glitter" is the poem's turning point — Puerto Rico's wealth is revealed as false and stolen
- The broken TV metaphor reduces Puerto Rico to damaged, stolen property
- "Belonged to someone else" ties everything together — imperialism as theft
- Airports serve as microcosms of each island's economic and cultural condition
- American freedom rhetoric ("Island of the free," "Give me your poor") is consistently ironised